Reviews: Jewelry-making books
Sep. 11th, 2007 10:44 amThe bookstore is pushing us to turn in our textbook requests for spring semester by month's end, which means i'm already slogging through candidates for required and recommended books on the topics covered in my spring seminar (of which there are many).
One of the aformentioned topics is jewelry, which in theatre can run the gamut in terms of crafts artisan responsibilities. You might find yourself restringing purchased necklaces to make them more durable, replacing traditional clasps with magnetic ones so a pendant can be jerked off of someone's neck angrily every night, replicating a huge brooch from a painting of Queen Elizabeth, aging brand-new metal to look old and tarnished, or sculpting and casting a giant medallion for a nobleman's chain of office (there'll be one of these in a forthcoming post--i'm doing this exact thing for our next show on the mainstage). Really, anything goes.
So, my students will be doing a unit on jewelry, and i want them to have a reference text for it. This has proved particularly difficult, since most books i'm finding out there are either on the "Joolree 4 Dummeez" level (think, bead-stringing projects for pre-teens) or are mostly project-based books--how to make specific projects outlined in a step-by-step fashion, rather than addressing basic skills and techniques.
On the intermediate/experienced end of things, there are three books i considered as possible texts for class:
Jewelry: Fundamentals of Metalsmithing by Tim McCreight
The Encyclopedia of Jewelry-Making Techniques by Jinks McGrath
The Complete Book of Jewelry-Making by Carles Codina
These three books are all, essentially, full of the same information. They're all good overviews of high-end jewelry-making techniques--think soldering, sawing metal with jewelry files, annealing, that sort of thing, rather than say, bead-stringing. You don't do a lot of this sort of thing as a craftsperson--specific jewelry designs often either get jobbed out or you "fudge" them for stage with materials like polymer clay, cast plastic and gold leaf, or precious-metal clay--but every so often something comes down the pike and you want a reference text.
Of these three, i'm going with the Tim McCreight one as the one that I'd recommend. Like i said, they all contain the same basic information, and it's really down to personal preference on layout, presentation, etc. McCreight's book is arranged in what feels to me like the most logical order, and has a good balance of visual and textual information. Most importantly for a theatre crafts artisan, he has good, concise, well-laid-out sections on soldering, jewelry adhesives, and patina recipes.
If you prefer lots of larger color photographs interspersed with small chunks of text, go for the Codina book. It's easy to digest, very visually laid out, and the book itself is fairly large-format. All this results in a book that makes jewelry-scale metalworking seem like something that's not very intimidating, which may be just right for someone seeking a good introductory text.
The Jinks McGrath book differs little from the McCreight book in images/info, but it's laid out in alphabetical order by process name regardless of difficulty (so you start out with annealing and end up with wirework). I know it bills itself as an "encyclopedia" but let's face it: there just aren't enough different topics under the "jewelry-making" umbrella for this book to even crack 200 pages, much less require the somewhat pedantic structure of an alphabetized "encyclopedia." The result is that the book seems far more dense and impenetrable than the information contained within really warrants. It's almost like the book is designed to make the stuff it covers seem more intimidating than it is. Counterproductive, i think, since i bet the average person on the street finds the idea of cutting metal with a hand-saw or etching it with acid to be already fairly intimidating. If you've taken several classes in jewelry-making and you already know what the tools and processes are, maybe you want this in your shop as a reference manual. I'm not knocking it; it's a good book. It's not right for my purposes though.
Creating Your Own Antique Jewelry by cRis Dupouy, rereleased in 2004 as Creating Your Own Jewelry: Taking Inspiration from Museum Masterpieces
This book isn't one i'm going to use for my class, but i think it's worth mentioning as something to check out. It's divided up by eras of time (antiquity, the Middle Ages, the Rennaissance, etc.), and is essentially a series of projects on how to make various pieces of jewelry depicted in actual historical resource images (oil paintings mostly), using Dupouy's particular style of working with polymer clay and glass stones.
From a theatrical perspective, it's not terribly useful as a reference text since once you get the basic techniques (and you get it as soon as you read through one project worth) you can then adapt the principles to whatever jewelry design your costume designer has rendered or provided research for. It's also probably not something of interest for historical reproduction folks either, since the pieces wind up being sometimes rather free interpretations of the jewelry depicted in the primary research rather than accurate replications. From a home enthusiast's perspective however, it seems like it could be a really fun text for someone with an interest in antique and vintage jewelry, who's seeking a step-by-step how-to book full of specific projects, and it's definitely a good inspiration text for a costume designer who has to do her/his own craftwork.
And, what i've still not found but would love to track down is a book that functions essentially as a reference for intermediate jewelry assemblage--one that addresses issues like how to properly secure crimp beads, pros and cons of different kinds of findings, overviews of bead types, stone cuts, cabochon uses, various hand tools, etc. Not "how to go from sheets of metal to art jewelry," which is what the three books i mentioned first really cover, but more of a text on assemblage with structural integrity, without a bunch of specific projects like "Make these six cute bracelets!"
One of the aformentioned topics is jewelry, which in theatre can run the gamut in terms of crafts artisan responsibilities. You might find yourself restringing purchased necklaces to make them more durable, replacing traditional clasps with magnetic ones so a pendant can be jerked off of someone's neck angrily every night, replicating a huge brooch from a painting of Queen Elizabeth, aging brand-new metal to look old and tarnished, or sculpting and casting a giant medallion for a nobleman's chain of office (there'll be one of these in a forthcoming post--i'm doing this exact thing for our next show on the mainstage). Really, anything goes.
So, my students will be doing a unit on jewelry, and i want them to have a reference text for it. This has proved particularly difficult, since most books i'm finding out there are either on the "Joolree 4 Dummeez" level (think, bead-stringing projects for pre-teens) or are mostly project-based books--how to make specific projects outlined in a step-by-step fashion, rather than addressing basic skills and techniques.
On the intermediate/experienced end of things, there are three books i considered as possible texts for class:
Jewelry: Fundamentals of Metalsmithing by Tim McCreight
The Encyclopedia of Jewelry-Making Techniques by Jinks McGrath
The Complete Book of Jewelry-Making by Carles Codina
These three books are all, essentially, full of the same information. They're all good overviews of high-end jewelry-making techniques--think soldering, sawing metal with jewelry files, annealing, that sort of thing, rather than say, bead-stringing. You don't do a lot of this sort of thing as a craftsperson--specific jewelry designs often either get jobbed out or you "fudge" them for stage with materials like polymer clay, cast plastic and gold leaf, or precious-metal clay--but every so often something comes down the pike and you want a reference text.
Of these three, i'm going with the Tim McCreight one as the one that I'd recommend. Like i said, they all contain the same basic information, and it's really down to personal preference on layout, presentation, etc. McCreight's book is arranged in what feels to me like the most logical order, and has a good balance of visual and textual information. Most importantly for a theatre crafts artisan, he has good, concise, well-laid-out sections on soldering, jewelry adhesives, and patina recipes.
If you prefer lots of larger color photographs interspersed with small chunks of text, go for the Codina book. It's easy to digest, very visually laid out, and the book itself is fairly large-format. All this results in a book that makes jewelry-scale metalworking seem like something that's not very intimidating, which may be just right for someone seeking a good introductory text.
The Jinks McGrath book differs little from the McCreight book in images/info, but it's laid out in alphabetical order by process name regardless of difficulty (so you start out with annealing and end up with wirework). I know it bills itself as an "encyclopedia" but let's face it: there just aren't enough different topics under the "jewelry-making" umbrella for this book to even crack 200 pages, much less require the somewhat pedantic structure of an alphabetized "encyclopedia." The result is that the book seems far more dense and impenetrable than the information contained within really warrants. It's almost like the book is designed to make the stuff it covers seem more intimidating than it is. Counterproductive, i think, since i bet the average person on the street finds the idea of cutting metal with a hand-saw or etching it with acid to be already fairly intimidating. If you've taken several classes in jewelry-making and you already know what the tools and processes are, maybe you want this in your shop as a reference manual. I'm not knocking it; it's a good book. It's not right for my purposes though.
Creating Your Own Antique Jewelry by cRis Dupouy, rereleased in 2004 as Creating Your Own Jewelry: Taking Inspiration from Museum Masterpieces
This book isn't one i'm going to use for my class, but i think it's worth mentioning as something to check out. It's divided up by eras of time (antiquity, the Middle Ages, the Rennaissance, etc.), and is essentially a series of projects on how to make various pieces of jewelry depicted in actual historical resource images (oil paintings mostly), using Dupouy's particular style of working with polymer clay and glass stones.
From a theatrical perspective, it's not terribly useful as a reference text since once you get the basic techniques (and you get it as soon as you read through one project worth) you can then adapt the principles to whatever jewelry design your costume designer has rendered or provided research for. It's also probably not something of interest for historical reproduction folks either, since the pieces wind up being sometimes rather free interpretations of the jewelry depicted in the primary research rather than accurate replications. From a home enthusiast's perspective however, it seems like it could be a really fun text for someone with an interest in antique and vintage jewelry, who's seeking a step-by-step how-to book full of specific projects, and it's definitely a good inspiration text for a costume designer who has to do her/his own craftwork.
And, what i've still not found but would love to track down is a book that functions essentially as a reference for intermediate jewelry assemblage--one that addresses issues like how to properly secure crimp beads, pros and cons of different kinds of findings, overviews of bead types, stone cuts, cabochon uses, various hand tools, etc. Not "how to go from sheets of metal to art jewelry," which is what the three books i mentioned first really cover, but more of a text on assemblage with structural integrity, without a bunch of specific projects like "Make these six cute bracelets!"